Iran Presidential Vote Pits ‘Engagement’ Against ‘Self-Reliance’

RFL/RE – Iranians are voting in a four-man presidential race that could reinvigorate efforts for an economic and diplomatic thaw with the West or draw the curtain on a four-year interlude in hard-line domination at all levels of government.

---

By Golnaz Esfandiari

https://www.rferl.org/fba22956-2fda-453b-ac98-9727d6daf5c7

The incumbent, relative moderate Hassan Rohani, and a conservative former prosecutor, Ebrahim Raisi, are widely regarded as the front-runners to lead the clerically dominated Islamic country of around 81 million people, which is laboring under high unemployment and struggling to seize economic opportunities abroad.

Rohani, who oversaw a breakthrough nuclear deal with world powers to ease international sanctions, has promised engagement with the West and more freedom for Iranians.

“Our nation will announce on May 19 whether it continues on the path of peace or chooses the path of tension,” the 68-year-old Rohani said in a recent campaign stop.

‘Efficiency Versus Inefficiency’

The 56-year-old Raisi is said to be trusted by the country’s most senior figure, Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, who — as the holder of ultimate political, military, and religious power in Iran — can easily derail a campaign or thwart the plans of a president. Raisi’s name has also come up as a possible successor to the 77-year-old Khamenei.

Raisi has echoed Khamenei’s and other hard-liners’ calls for self-sufficiency to improve the economy, and he has accused Rohani of projecting weakness to the world.

Raisi has described the voters’ choice as one between “inefficiency” and “efficiency.” A veteran of the powerful judiciary, Raisi has alleged that Rohani has significantly worsened inequalities in Iranian society.

“Why have you increased the gap between the poor and rich so much with your misguided policies?” Raisi said in a May 16 speech in the Iranian capital. He accused Rohani of overreliance on foreign investment to fix economic problems.

An independent poll showed Rohani nearly 20 points ahead of Raisi on the eve of the vote, although polling is notoriously unreliable in Iran and many voters reportedly remained undecided.

Two of the original six approved candidates dropped out of the race days before the election, and the two others that remain — conservative Mostafa Mirsalim, a former culture minister, and centrist Mostafa Hashemitaba, a former head of the Iranian National Olympic Committee — are regarded as distant outsiders.

Khamenei cast his vote in Tehran shortly after polls opened at 8 a.m. local time (0330 GMT/UTC), and called on Iranians to turn out in huge numbers for the poll.

“Everyone should vote in this important election,” he said, adding that “the destiny of the country is in the hand of Iranians.”

After casting his ballot in the capital, Rohani said that whoever is elected as president should be supported by all the nation.

“Any candidate who is elected should be helped to accomplish this heavy responsibility,” he said. “Anyone who is elected must be helped from tomorrow with unity, happiness, and joy.”

Raisi told journalists that everyone should “completely surrender to the result of the election.”

“If I, for instance, find the result undesirable, it should not lead to disruption of the election,” he said after voting.

State television showed long lines outside polling stations in several cities.

A man in an affluent Tehran neighborhood told RFE/RL he waited for about two hours to cast his ballot. “When I left the line was even longer,” the man, who did not want to be identified, said via the messaging app Telegram.

Also speaking via Telegram, a woman said that that voters at a polling station in a mosque in the capital were urging each other to vote for Rohani. “It was very crowded. There was a feeling of hope but also fear,” said the woman, who did not want to be named.

Voting is scheduled to run until 6 p.m., though Iran routinely extends voting for several hours in elections.

Turnout Could Be Crucial

Analysts suggest a big turnout could benefit Rohani, as high participation in the past has led to the election of reformist or moderate candidates.

“In a high turnout, [as] we have seen in the past elections, it is people who want to have a more moderate person in power who vote,” Washington-based analyst Rasool Nafisi tells RFE/RL.

Karim Sadjadpour, a senior analyst with the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, says Rohani and Raisi must try to appeal to two competing constituencies — young Iranians who make up more than half of the population and yearn for freedom and interaction with the world, and hard-core regime supporters who staunchly oppose opening up the country to outside influence.

He characterizes those segments as “a young, modern Iranian population eager for change, and an entrenched, dogmatic military and clerical establishment eager to crush change.”

“Raisi is the enthusiastic candidate of the latter, while Rohani is the default candidate of the former,” he says.

WATCH: Iranians Face ‘Historic Decision’ In Presidential Vote

The election is the first since the landmark nuclear deal in 2015 that resulted in significant limits on Tehran’s most sensitive nuclear activities, which many in the West believed were part of an effort to build atomic weapons, in exchange for sanctions relief.

Rohani has managed to slash inflation from official figures of about 30 percent to 9 percent and spur economic growth. But unemployment remains at an estimated 12 percent, with the rate among young people closer to 30 percent.

Economic Issues

A poll issued in April suggested that the economy is the key issue for many voters, who are frustrated at the slow pace of economic recovery since the nuclear accord.

Raisi has tapped into that frustration to attack Rohani for failing to translate the deal into better living standards for average Iranians.

Rohani has accused Raisi, who has promised to triple cash handouts to the poor and create up to 4 million jobs, of making unrealistic promises and deceiving voters.

Rohani has been blunt in references to Raisi’s past. The ex-prosecutor is a former member of the so-called death commissions involved in the summary executions of thousands of political prisoners in the 1980s.

Speaking on May 8, Rohani said voters did not want someone who in the four decades since Iran’s 1979 revolution has only known how to “execute and jail,” adding that the era of extremists is over.

Raisi has countered by saying Rohani tries to cover up his failures by creating fear among Iranians. “He says things such as ‘they want to create a wall’ [to separate men and women],” Raisi said, then added in an allusion to wayward officials. “I say we will create a tall wall to [counter] the plunderers of the rights of the people.”

Former reformist President Mohammad Khatami and three main opposition figures who remain under house arrest have endorsed Rohani. He has called on voters to give him another four years to achieve all his promises, including rebuilding an economy that has suffered under sanctions and mismanagement.

Talk of Raisi as a possible successor to Supreme Leader Khamenei could raise the stakes in Iran’s carefully vetted election just eight years after a presidential vote sparked the biggest street protests in Iran since iconic student demonstrations in 1999.

Raisi is believed to enjoy broad support within the hard-line Islamic Revolutionary Guards Corps (IRGC) military organization.

Ali Vaez, a senior Iran analyst with the International Crisis Group (ICG), says Raisi faces an uphill battle, in part because of a perceived lack of executive experience and even charisma.

“His defeat would be a double-edged sword for his ambition to succeed the current supreme leader: the election would raise his profile and broaden his support-base, but it would be a setback — albeit not a fatal one, as popularity is not the most determining factor for ascending to the pinnacle of power in the Islamic republic,” Vaez told RFE/RL via e-mail.

Vetted Candidates

Rohani’s supporters are warning that the future of their country is at stake and say they don’t want to end up embroiled in conflict like some of their Middle Eastern neighbors.

“If you want [Iran to become] Syria or Iraq, vote for Raisi. If you want peace, security, and freedom, vote for Rohani,” a listener told RFE/RL’s Radio Farda.

But Raisi supporters argue that theirs is a better choice for the country.

Raisi heads one of Iran’s wealthiest charities, the Astan Qods Razavi charity that oversees the majority-Shi’ite country’s holiest shrine, but he has never held elected office.

“He is an efficient manager and also because he is mindful of the weak and deprived classes of the society,” another Iranian says, “a class that is being crushed under economic problems.”

There are no high-profile calls for a boycott, but some Iranians have vowed not to vote, citing the undemocratic nature of a system in which potential candidates are vetted by the hard-line Guardians Council.

“I won’t participate in this show,” a 42-year-old woman said via Instagram from the Iranian capital.

About 55 million people are eligible to vote in Iran, where the voting age is 18.

Ballot counting will start at midnight (1930 GMT/UTC) and final results are expected within 24 hours of the closure of polls, state television reported.

If no candidate wins more than 50 percent of the votes, the top two candidates will compete in a runoff on May 26.